In some parts of Northeast Oregon, victims of sexual assault face an added indignity — a long drive to get a rape exam (copy)
Published 6:00 am Thursday, January 11, 2024
- Grant County District Attorney Jim Carpenter said testimony from a SANE nurse can be a big help in a rape prosecution.
JOHN DAY — Being sexually assaulted is a devastating experience, but for the victim, the ordeal doesn’t end there.
Next comes the rape exam, a combination medical and forensic procedure that involves treating the victim’s injuries while also gathering evidence that can be used to arrest and prosecute the assailant.
For a survivor of sexual assault, it requires an act of courage to go to a hospital and ask to have a rape exam performed. So imagine how it would feel to be told the hospital doesn’t have anyone with the training to do the exam.
That’s currently the case at John Day’s Blue Mountain Hospital, the only hospital in Grant County, which has not had a trained sexual assault examiner on staff since the beginning of 2021. The nearest facility that can do the exam is St. Charles Medical Center in Bend, which means a three-hour drive — each way.
“What happens sometimes is the victim just says, ‘I’ve had enough. I want to go home,’ ” said Debbie Morris, director of nursing at Blue Mountain Hospital. “So what happens if they don’t press charges is the criminal just gets away with it.”
Grant County is certainly not alone. Sexual assault nurse examiners — known as SANE nurses, or simply as SANEs — are in short supply throughout the state, particularly in rural areas. At the moment, there are only 16 in all of Northeast Oregon, and only three of those are certified by the state. Three counties in the region — Grant, Morrow and Baker — currently have no one available to do rape exams.
Wallowa Memorial Hospital in Enterprise has one sexual assault nurse examiner on staff.
Blue Mountain Hospital has two nurses who are in the process of training to become certified SANEs, and other hospitals in Northeast Oregon are looking for candidates to do the same. But finding them isn’t easy. Hospitals are already grappling with a nursing shortage, and recruiting nurses willing to take on the added burden of performing rape exams is challenging at best.
And in the meantime, people who have been sexually assaulted — usually women, but not always — may find themselves having to travel long distances in the aftermath of the most traumatic experience of their lives to get the medical care they need in pursuit of justice.
“It’s a need,” Morris said. “We would just like to take care of our residents here and not have to have them go through that. … It’s traumatic enough.”
Support is available
Resources are available to help survivors of sexual assault. Every county in Northeast Oregon has a nonprofit rape crisis center that can provide a wide range of services, such as a 24-hour hotline, emergency shelter, safety planning, legal advocacy, support groups and referral to other services.
Heart of Grant County, located in John Day, is a typical example. And like similar organizations elsewhere, the group guarantees confidentiality for survivors.
“We are not mandatory reporters, so everything is confidential,” said Beth Simonsen, the nonprofit’s executive director.
“Sometimes we have people who just need to come in and tell us their story. They need to talk to somebody but can’t talk to their family, can’t talk to their friends because they feel somebody’s going to blab.”
In addition to Simonsen, Heart of Grant County has two advocates on staff: Rayme Lacey and Elisha Nightingale. At least one of them is always available to help survivors of sexual assault. That includes accompanying them to a rape exam, even if that means driving them to Bend, staying by their side throughout the procedure and driving them back home — or wherever they feel safe.
“They don’t have to go through it alone,” Lacey said. “We’ll give you some of our strength.”
Survivors of sexual assault may need that strength to get through a rape exam — especially if they have to travel a long distance to get it.
From John Day, it’s a three-hour drive to St. Charles Bend, which is currently the nearest facility with SANE nurses reliably available. But that doesn’t mean the nurse is waiting when the patient gets there. Typically, Nightingale said, the hospital doesn’t call the SANE nurse in until the assault victim checks in.
The exam itself typically takes four to six hours, sometimes longer. And in order to preserve evidence that can be used to prosecute the attacker, survivors are told not to eat, drink, shower or use the bathroom until after the examination is complete.
Earlier this year, Lacey worked with a client who had been sexually assaulted but decided not to get the exam after learning she’d have to travel to Bend — even though Lacey offered to drive her there.
The Oregon Attorney General’s Sexual Assault Task Force runs the state’s certification program for sexual assault nurse examiners. And while medical practitioners who are not certified can still perform rape exams, certification ensures that the provider has the latest training in compassionate and trauma-informed care and is doing enough exams to keep current on the skills involved.
And according to Mei Pomegranate, SANE coordinator for the task force, there aren’t nearly enough certified practitioners to go around.
“We have somewhere in the neighborhood of 100 certified SANEs (statewide),” Pomegranate said. In the six counties that make up Northeast Oregon, “there is a total of three certified SANEs, which is pretty bleak.”
Around the region
There are seven hospitals scattered around the six counties that make up Northeast Oregon, an area of 18,000 square miles. None is licensed for more than 25 beds, and most staff to a lower level because of limited patient volume.
Baker County is a prime example of the need for more SANE nurses.
Millie Joseph recently returned to the position of executive director at MayDay Inc., the nonprofit rape crisis center in Baker City, after being away for six years.
“When I was doing it before, we had an excellent group of sexual assault nurses,” she said. “So I never had to take anyone out of town.”
But the situation has changed. At the moment, there are no trained sexual assault nurse examiners on staff at Saint Alphonsus Medical Center in Baker City, the only hospital in Baker County, and just one at Saint Alphonsus in Ontario, in neighboring Malheur County 70 miles from Baker City. The next-nearest options are in La Grande, 43 miles, and Pendleton, 95 miles.
“If we have to go clear to Pendleton, we’re talking about an hour and a half to two hours, depending on the roads,” Joseph said. “None of them are close, and in the winter it can take even longer because of the weather.”
Shelly Cutler, a spokeswoman for Saint Alphonsus, said the health care system is trying to improve the situation at its Baker City hospital.
“We are actively trying to recruit another (SANE) from our staff of nurses,” Cutler said. “It’s tough to retain a nurse because it’s so emotionally draining.”
Sexual assault survivors in Morrow County are referred to Good Shepherd Medical Center in Hermiston, 45 minutes away in Umatilla County. When they get there, they find the best-staffed hospital in the region for sexual assault nurse examiners.
“Good Shepherd Health Care System has seven SANE nurses on staff,” hospital spokesperson Caitlin Cozad said. “All seven of our SANE nurses are trained and maintain competencies, while one is certified.”
Even with seven trained examiners on staff, though, there’s no guarantee that one will always be available to do an exam. And in a rural region like Northeast Oregon, that can still mean a long drive to get care.
“We are committed to ensuring our patients receive the care they need,” Cozad said, “and in the few cases that a SANE nurse has not been available, we have called surrounding hospitals, sometimes even Portland hospitals when needed to facilitate a transfer of the patient so they can get the forensic exam.”
Umatilla County’s other hospital, CHI St. Anthony’s in Pendleton, has three SANEs: two nurses, neither certified, and a nurse-practitioner who is certified to perform pediatric exams.
A different approach
Union County follows a different model when it comes to rape exams.
“We actually have a SANE nurse that works with our organization personally,” said Jordan Kaufman, executive director of Shelter From the Storm, a nonprofit rape and domestic violence crisis center based in Island City.
“Grande Ronde Hospital will call and let us know someone wants an exam done, and we will set it up and do the exam at our office.”
Jamie Jo Haddock, a nurse practitioner who works out of Grande Ronde Hospital’s clinic in Elgin, has been performing sexual assault exams at Shelter From the Storm for years.
With a shortage of SANE nurses throughout much of the region, Haddock is sometimes called on to do exams for rape survivors from neighboring counties. This year alone, she has had referrals from Pendleton, Enterprise and Baker County.
“I am technically on call all the time,” Haddock said. “I would like to share that responsibility with others.”
When Haddock is not available, rape survivors in Union County will sometimes be referred to Wallowa Memorial Hospital in Enterprise, which has one sexual assault nurse examiner on staff.
Like other advocates around the region, Kaufman said it’s important that survivors of sexual assault be able to get the care they need at their local hospital in the immediate aftermath of an attack.
April Brock, nurse manager for the emergency department at Grande Ronde Hospital, said she understands the need for more trained nurse examiners, but for a small hospital in a sparsely populated area, low patient volume creates a challenge.
“We continue to offer training opportunities to staff who are interested,” Brock said. “However, the total number of adult SANE cases are currently covered with the number of staff we have. Maintaining competency and providing coverage is an important balance for this vulnerable population.”
Getting the exam
A forensic exam can be conducted anytime within five days of the assault, but for purposes of evidence collection it should be done within 84 hours — and for purposes of caring for the survivor’s injuries, it should be done as soon as possible.
In most cases, the cost of the exam and related testing and medication is covered by the state. Survivors are allowed to have a personal representative of their choice with them throughout the exam, and part of the protocol involves calling the local rape crisis center to send an advocate who can provide that service as soon as the survivor arrives at the hospital.
The exam also routinely includes testing for pregnancy, sexually transmitted diseases, HIV, human papilloma virus, hepatitis and tetanus, as well as medication when appropriate.
Evidence collection for a potential prosecution is also an important part of the exam. It includes photographic documentation of the survivor’s appearance and physical condition, including any injuries. Clothing worn at the time of the attack is collected, as well as hair samples, and swabs are taken to collect traces of the attacker’s DNA.
Working on the problemShannon Rose, executive director of the Oregon Sexual Assault Task Force, said her organization is doing all it can to address the statewide shortage of sexual assault nurse examiners.
In addition to providing training and technical assistance for SANEs, the task force is trying to build stronger partnerships with the medical community, which Rose said could do more to support staff members who want to become certified sexual assault examiners. She’d also like to see more government funding.
“Oregon historically has had one of the highest rates of sexual assault in the country,” Rose said. “We need our state to step up and say, ‘We’re going to provide the funding and resources needed.’”
Where to get help
If you’ve been sexually assaulted, you can call the nonprofit rape crisis center in your area. Crisis hotlines are staffed 24 hours a day. A counselor can speak with you confidentially about your experience, explain your options for medical care and reporting, and offer information on additional resources that may help.
WALLOWA COUNTY
Safe Harbors
Crisis line: 541-426-6565
Office: 541-426-4004
GRANT COUNTY
Heart of Grant County
Crisis line: 541-620-1342
Office: 541-575-4335
BAKER COUNTY
MayDay Inc.
Crisis line: 541-523-4134
Toll free: 888-213-4134
Office: 541-523-9472
MORROW COUNTY
Domestic Violence Services Inc.
Crisis line: 800-833-1161
UMATILLA COUNTY
Domestic Violence Services Inc.
Crisis line: 800-833-1161
Hermiston office:
541-567-0424
Pendleton office:
541-276-3322
UNION COUNTY
Shelter from the Storm
Crisis line: 541-963-9261
Office: 541-963-7226
More Information
A more comprehensive version of this story is on the Wallowa County Chieftain’s website, wallowa.com.